Most beginners should start free with Proton VPN Free and only pay once they know what they need. If you do pay, the four VPNs below all have independently audited no-logs policies, and the right one depends on what you value: privacy, extras, devices or anonymity. One honest note: Proton VPN is the only one we’ve used ourselves, every day for more than three years. The other three are picks based on independent audits and published documentation, and we say which is which.
Last reviewed: October 2026. Prices and plans change, so check the official site before you buy.
This guide contains affiliate links. If you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. How we stay independent.
The short answer: which VPN suits you?
| VPN | Choose it if… | Skip it if… |
|---|---|---|
| Proton VPN → (what we use) | You want to start free, then upgrade to a privacy-first VPN with yearly audits | You need it on more than 10 devices at once |
| NordVPN → | You want extras in one app: malware blocking, dark web alerts, Double VPN, a dedicated IP option | You want a free plan, or hate big jumps at renewal |
| Surfshark → | You want unlimited devices for the whole household on one plan | You want a provider audited every year (Surfshark: 2023 and 2025) |
| ExpressVPN → 2-year plan + 4 extra months via our link | You want a big-name VPN with the most independent audits and a simple app | You’re on a tight budget: it renews at about $100 a year or more |
| Mullvad → | You want to sign up without an email address and pay a flat €5 a month | You want long-term discounts, extra features or more than 5 devices |
Some links in this table are affiliate links. They never change which pick we recommend.
Free or paid: which do you need?
A free VPN is enough if you mostly want privacy on café or hotel Wi-Fi now and then. Proton VPN Free is the one free VPN we recommend: no ads, no data cap, and its no-logs policy covers free servers too. The trade-offs are one device at a time and a limited choice of countries.
Pay for a VPN if you want it on several devices, need specific countries, use it daily while traveling, or want extras like ad blocking. Avoid unknown free VPN apps: running a VPN costs money, so if you aren’t paying, ask how the company makes its money.
Still not sure you need one? Read Do I really need a VPN? first. For most people, a password manager and two-factor login come first.
Side by side
| Proton VPN | NordVPN | Surfshark | ExpressVPN | Mullvad | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Based in | Switzerland | Panama | Netherlands | British Virgin Islands | Sweden |
| No-logs audits | Securitum, yearly since 2022 (latest 2026) | Deloitte, six times (latest Dec 2025) | Deloitte, 2023 and 2025 | KPMG (latest covers Feb 2025); 27 independent audits in total | Several published independent audits |
| Free plan | Yes (1 device) | No | No | No | No |
| Devices at once | 10 | 10 | Unlimited | 10 (Basic plan) | 5 |
| Intro price, 2-year plan | From about $2.99/mo | From about $3.49/mo | From about $2.49/mo | From about $3/mo (28 months, Basic) | €5/mo flat, no long-term discount |
| After the intro term | About $83.88/yr (2-year Plus) | Typically 55–100% more | About $79/yr (Starter) | $99.95/yr (Basic) | Same €5/mo |
| Money-back window | 30 days (pro-rated) | 30 days | 30 days | 30 days | 14 days (not for cash payments) |
| Sign-up | Account number, no email needed |
Prices are introductory offers that change often; check today’s price before you buy. NordVPN and Surfshark belong to the same holding company, Nord Security, but say they run as separate services with separate infrastructure.
Proton VPN: the one we use (hands-on)
We’ve used Proton VPN on our own phones and laptops for more than three years, on hotel, airport and café Wi-Fi at home and abroad. It’s been quick to connect and stable enough that we forget it’s on. The free plan is the easiest way to try a VPN without risk, and paid plans add 10 devices, more countries, Secure Core and the NetShield ad and malware blocker. Read our long-term Proton VPN review, or compare it head to head in Proton VPN vs NordVPN.
Choose Proton VPN if you want to start free and keep privacy first. Skip it if you need more than 10 devices at once. Try Proton VPN Free →
NordVPN: the most extras (research-based)
NordVPN documents a long feature list: real-time malware and harmful-site blocking, Double VPN, Onion over VPN, obfuscated servers, Meshnet, an optional dedicated IP and dark web alerts. Its no-logs policy has been assessed by Deloitte six times. There’s no free plan, and renewals typically cost 55% to 100% more than the intro price. NordVPN often runs limited-time deals.
Choose NordVPN if you want lots of tools in one app. Skip it if you want a free plan. Check NordVPN’s current deal →
Surfshark: best for big households (research-based)
Surfshark’s standout is unlimited devices on every plan, handy for a family with lots of phones, tablets and laptops. Deloitte verified its no-logs policy in 2023 and again in 2025, and the company is based in the Netherlands. Its cheapest 2-year plans start low, and the Starter plan renews at about $79 a year.
Choose Surfshark if you need to cover many devices on one subscription. Skip it if yearly audits matter most to you. See Surfshark’s plans →
Mullvad: the most private sign-up (research-based)
Mullvad, from Sweden, takes a minimalist approach: you get an account number instead of creating an account with an email address, it charges a flat €5 a month whether you buy one month or a year, and it accepts cash and cryptocurrency (with a 10% discount for crypto). It covers 5 devices and has a 14-day money-back guarantee, except for cash payments. It has published several independent audits.
Choose Mullvad if you want to share as little personal information as possible. Skip it if you want discounts for paying longer or more than 5 devices. See Mullvad →
ExpressVPN: the most audited (research-based)
ExpressVPN has had 27 independent security audits, more than most rivals, and KPMG confirmed its no-logs policy as of February 2025. Every plan includes a 30-day money-back guarantee for new users. The trade-off is price: the Basic plan starts at about $3 a month for the first 28 months (a 2-year plan plus 4 extra months, which is the offer our link opens), then renews at $99.95 a year, and higher tiers add devices (12 or 14) and extras.
Choose ExpressVPN if you want a well-known, heavily audited VPN that’s easy to set up. Skip it if you want the lowest long-term cost or a free plan. See ExpressVPN’s plans →
How to choose any VPN
- Look for a recent, independent no-logs audit by a named firm. All four here have one.
- Check the renewal price, not just the first-term deal, and put a reminder in your calendar a month before it renews.
- Count your devices. 5 is enough for one person; families may need 10 or unlimited.
- Use the money-back window to test it on your own devices and trips.
- Turn on the kill switch and auto-connect on untrusted Wi-Fi once it’s installed.
Frequently asked questions
Are free VPNs safe?
Many aren’t: some show ads, sell data or limit you heavily. Proton VPN Free is the exception we recommend, because it has no ads, no data cap and an audited no-logs policy that covers free servers.
Which VPN is cheapest in the long run?
It depends how long you keep it. Intro deals make NordVPN, Surfshark and Proton cheap for the first term, but they renew higher. Mullvad’s flat €5 a month never changes, which makes long-term costs easy to predict.
Will a VPN protect me from scams?
No. A VPN hides your browsing on the network, but phishing links and fake websites work just as well over a VPN. Read AI-written phishing: the new red flags.
Do I need a VPN at home?
Usually not on your own password-protected Wi-Fi, unless you want privacy from your internet provider. It’s most useful on public Wi-Fi and when traveling. See is public Wi-Fi safe? and our travel security kit.
Is it legal to use a VPN?
In the US, yes. Some countries restrict or ban VPNs, so check local rules before you travel.
The bottom line
Start with Proton VPN Free. If you outgrow it, pick by what matters to you: Proton for privacy (what we use), NordVPN for extras, Surfshark for unlimited devices, or Mullvad for an anonymous sign-up and a flat price. Whatever you choose, check the renewal price and use the refund window. See all our picks on the recommended tools page.
Sources
- Proton VPN: Plans explained and CyberInsider: Proton VPN passes no-logs audit (2026)
- NordVPN: Features and sixth no-logs assessment (December 2025)
- Surfshark: Deloitte no-logs assessment (June 2025) and Wikipedia: Surfshark B.V. (headquarters, Nord Security merger)
- ExpressVPN: Pricing and plans, Engadget: KPMG no-logs audit (2025) and SecurityBrief: 27 audits (2026), plus ExpressVPN: BVI company (headquarters)
- Mullvad: Pricing and TechRadar: Mullvad audit coverage
- Security.org: NordVPN pricing and Proton VPN pricing (2026)
- CostBench: Surfshark pricing and NordVPN vs Proton VPN renewals
Facts and prices were checked in October 2026 and can change. This guide is general information, not legal, financial or professional advice.